Reflections on Innovation: Have We Reached a Standstill?
Written on
Chapter 1: The Illusion of Continuous Progress
Growing up during the 70s and 80s, I was under the impression that innovation was a straightforward path. I thought that we were bound to see more advancements in the future than we had in the past. After spending more than two decades in technology firms, I believed that Moore’s Law represented an exponential growth that extended beyond just computing capabilities.
Indeed, Moore’s Law illustrates the rapid advancement in computing power.
I assumed that various other facets of human existence were also advancing at a similar exponential rate. By this point in 2023, I anticipated flying cars, rapid transit, and routine trips to the moon.
However, I was mistaken. Recently, I delved into the thought-provoking book Invention and Innovation: A Brief History of Hype and Failure by Vaclav Smil, which presented a compelling argument.
Smil posits that our innovative capabilities may have peaked not just in the last five or ten years, but quite possibly 140 years ago.
Section 1.1: The Golden Age of Innovation
The 1880s might be considered the pinnacle of human innovation, marked by groundbreaking advancements such as:
- Electric generation and distribution
- Coal and hydroelectric power plants
- Wind turbines for electricity
- Steam turbines
- Light bulbs
- Internal combustion engines
- The modern bicycle
- The modern battery
- Aluminum production
- The ballpoint pen
- Radio waves
- Coca-Cola
While other decades also contributed notable inventions, such as the nuclear power in the 1950s or the CD-ROM in the 1980s, none match the transformational impact of the 1880s.
Section 1.2: Comparing Past and Present Innovations
Today, we enjoy remarkable gadgets and digital platforms, and our economic growth has indeed been exponential. Social media and mobile technology have reshaped our communication and information-sharing methods.
Yet, our daily lives remain fundamentally unchanged from those 50 years ago. Reflecting on my upbringing in the 1970s, I remember living in a home equipped with electricity, central air conditioning, television, and various appliances. Although my current home boasts more advanced features and connectivity, the essence of life remains largely the same.
Section 1.3: Reasons Behind the Slowdown in Innovation
Several factors might explain the stagnation in significant innovations:
- The role of the inventor has diminished; now we primarily have coders and entrepreneurs, but where are the true inventors?
- The current business environment may not foster the kind of long-term thinking and investment that led to major breakthroughs in the past.
- The rise of state-run educational institutions coincided with the rapid innovation of the 1880s, suggesting a possible link between widespread education and increased invention.
Chapter 2: The Path Forward
Is it possible for us to rekindle the spirit of innovation seen in the 1880s?
Absolutely, but it will require substantial effort. I am reminded of a moment from The West Wing, where President Bartlet poses similar inquiries:
What will push us to strive harder and reach new heights? The eradication of smallpox was once viewed as the greatest humanitarian accomplishment of its time. Surely, we have the potential to achieve something equally monumental again.